Best Murder Mystery Party Kits

With so many choices out there, picking the right takes time.

We compared dozens of products to figure out which ones are worth your attention.

The best option wasn’t the most expensive — but it delivered where it counts.

1
Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme Medium English 4-20 Players
Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme Medium English...
9.9
Amazon.com
2
Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme Medium English 4-20 Players
Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme Medium English...
9.7
Amazon.com
3
Replay-able Haunted House Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host A Halloween Dinner Party Game Night – Classic Monsters Fancy Dress Dinner PartyV2 English 4-20 Players
Replay-able Haunted House Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host A Halloween Dinner Party Game Night – Classic Monsters Fancy Dress...
9.3
Amazon.com
4
16 Pieces Halloween Crime Scene Decorations Kit Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game Supplies Includes Body Silhouette Crime Scene Tape Evidence Markers and Blody Sticker Home for Crime Scene Party Decor
16 Pieces Halloween Crime Scene Decorations Kit Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game Supplies Includes Body Silhouette Crime Scene Tape Evidence Markers and...
8.7
Amazon.com
5
Replay-able Vampire Ball Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host A Halloween Dinner Party Game Night - Vampire Theme English 4-20 Players
Replay-able Vampire Ball Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host A Halloween Dinner Party Game Night - Vampire Theme English 4-20 Players
7.7
Amazon.com

Top Pick

This is the product that stood out most — for performance, price, and overall value.

Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme Medium English...

$35.00 $42.42
PRIMEPRIME
in stock
Amazon.com
Amazon price updated: October 14, 2025 10:45 pm

Features

Is Adult Product
Size 11 x 8.5 x 2 inches
Edition Standard Edition
  • HOST YOUR OWN 1920s MURDER MYSTERY PARTY - Step into the Roaring Twenties with this murder mystery game kit, perfect for in-person or virtual play with friends and family.
  • 1.5 - 3 HOURS OF 1920s-THEMED GAMEPLAY - Experience the glamour and intrigue of the Jazz Age in a captivating night of mystery.
  • THE HOST CAN PLAY - Themed detective recordings and 1920s scripts allow the host to play along without knowing the murderer.
  • REPLAYABLE JAZZ AGE MYSTERY - With a randomly selected murderer, every 1920s game night offers a fresh and exciting experience.
  • FLEXIBLE GENDER ROLES IN THE ROARING TWENTIES - Enjoy character roles that embody the 1920s, adaptable for players of any gender.
  • EVIDENCE PACKS: This kit includes evidence packs used in rounds 2,3 and 4

More Worth Considering

Here are the other options we recommend. Each brings something different to the table, depending on what you’re looking for.

Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme Medium English...

$35.00 $42.42
PRIMEPRIME
in stock
Amazon.com
Amazon price updated: October 14, 2025 10:45 pm

Features

Is Adult Product
Size 11 x 8.5 x 2 inches
Edition Standard Edition
  • HOST YOUR OWN 1920s MURDER MYSTERY PARTY - Step into the Roaring Twenties with this murder mystery game kit, perfect for in-person or virtual play with friends and family.
  • 1.5 - 3 HOURS OF 1920s-THEMED GAMEPLAY - Experience the glamour and intrigue of the Jazz Age in a captivating night of mystery.
  • THE HOST CAN PLAY - Themed detective recordings and 1920s scripts allow the host to play along without knowing the murderer.
  • REPLAYABLE JAZZ AGE MYSTERY - With a randomly selected murderer, every 1920s game night offers a fresh and exciting experience.
  • FLEXIBLE GENDER ROLES IN THE ROARING TWENTIES - Enjoy character roles that embody the 1920s, adaptable for players of any gender.
  • EVIDENCE PACKS: This kit includes evidence packs used in rounds 2,3 and 4

Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme Medium English...

$39.99
PRIMEPRIME
in stock
Amazon.com
Amazon price updated: October 14, 2025 10:45 pm

Features

Size Small
  • HOST YOUR OWN WILD WEST MURDER MYSTERY PARTY - Saddle up for a night of Wild West intrigue with this murder mystery kit, ideal for in-person or virtual play.
  • 1.5 - 3 HOURS OF WILD WEST-THEMED GAMEPLAY - Experience the thrill of the frontier with a captivating murder mystery set in the Wild West.
  • THE HOST CAN PLAY - With themed recordings and Wild West scripts, the host can join the posse without spoiling the game.
  • REPLAYABLE WILD WEST ADVENTURE - Each game night in the Wild West is different, thanks to a randomly selected murderer.
  • FLEXIBLE GENDER ROLES IN THE FRONTIER - Roles are designed to capture the spirit of the Wild West, with flexibility in gender.
  • EVIDENCE PACKS: This kit includes Evidence folders used in rounds1, 2,3 and 4 filled with crucial clues

Replay-able Haunted House Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host A Halloween Dinner Party Game Night – Classic Monsters Fancy Dress...

$39.99
PRIMEPRIME
in stock
Amazon.com
Amazon price updated: October 14, 2025 10:45 pm

Features

Color Orange and Black
Size Medium
  • HOST YOUR OWN MONSTER MANSION MURDER MYSTERY PARTY - Step into a spooky mansion with classic Halloween characters for a thrilling murder mystery game, ideal for in-person or virtual play.
  • 1.5 - 3 HOURS OF MONSTER MANSION-THEMED GAMEPLAY - Solve a chilling mystery alongside iconic monsters in a haunted mansion.
  • THE HOST CAN PLAY - Themed recordings and monster scripts allow the host to join the Halloween fun without spoiling the game.
  • REPLAYABLE MONSTER MYSTERY - Each Halloween night is different, with a new outcome every time, thanks to a randomly selected murderer.
  • FLEXIBLE GENDER ROLES FOR CLASSIC MONSTERS - Enjoy roles that fit the Halloween theme, adaptable for any gender.
  • EVIDENCE PACKS: This kit includes Evidence folders used in rounds 2 and 3 filled with crucial clues.

16 Pieces Halloween Crime Scene Decorations Kit Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game Supplies Includes Body Silhouette Crime Scene Tape Evidence Markers and...

$15.69
PRIMEPRIME
in stock
Amazon.com
Amazon price updated: October 14, 2025 10:45 pm

Features

Part Number MS22025
  • PACKAGE INCLUDES:our crime scene decoration included 1x crie scene body silhouette,1 x bright yellow CAUTION tape,10 x photo evidence markers with 0-10 number and 4 x window clings handprint footprint blod footprint sticker,these set has essential items for your party
  • SUITABLE SIZE: the body silhouette measures about 152 x 76 cm/ 59 x 29.9 inch, the CAUTION tape is 7.5 cm x 20 m/ 2.9inch x 65.6 feet,the blody handprint footprint measures about 35 x 25 cm/ 13.8 x 9.8 inch;and the evidence markers measure 8 x 8cm/3.1 x 3.1inch;The crim scene evidence decorations are suitable for large space murd mystery party use
  • Easy to Use:You can put the body silhouette on the ground and place some evidence markers and handprint footprint blod footprint sticker around it anywhere you want,then use CAUTION tape around and protect the crim scene which create a crim-scene atmosphere, suitable for decorating your room, garden and parties
  • WILDLY APPLICATION:this crim scene decorations set can be used in many parties such as halloween props, halloween birthday party decorations, zombie party,special events, crim scene party, murd party, crim scene party and so on
  • Reliable Material: the murd mystery crim scene body silhouette are made of quality plastic,which is waterproof and solid,The photo evidence markers are made of paper, sturdy and reliable,the stickers are made of quality PVC, both of them are sturdy and long lasting, can be applied for a long time

Replay-able Vampire Ball Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host A Halloween Dinner Party Game Night - Vampire Theme English 4-20 Players

$39.99
PRIMEPRIME
in stock
Amazon.com
Amazon price updated: October 14, 2025 10:45 pm

Features

Color Black, Red, White
  • HOST YOUR OWN VAMPIRE BALL MURDER MYSTERY PARTY - Enter a world of gothic elegance with this vampire-themed murder mystery kit, perfect for in-person or virtual play.
  • 1.5 - 3 HOURS OF VAMPIRE BALL-THEMED GAMEPLAY - Experience a night of dark romance and mystery at an elegant vampire ball.
  • THE HOST CAN PLAY - Themed recordings and vampire scripts allow the host to join the nocturnal intrigue without spoiling the game.
  • REPLAYABLE GOTHIC MYSTERY - Each vampire ball night is unique, with a new murderer randomly selected to keep the suspense alive.
  • FLEXIBLE GENDER ROLES IN A GOTHIC SETTING - Enjoy character roles that embrace the vampire theme, adaptable for any gender.
  • EVIDENCE PACKS: This kit includes Evidence folders used in rounds1,2,3 and 4 filled with crucial clues.

Tags:

Digital Wellness Labs
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart